2d face recognition system vs 3d face recognition system
Biometric face
recognition system is considered the most efficient technology in biometrics.
Fingerprint devices stand the risk of duplication and easy hacking. Besides, it
may deny access if the fingers are wet or dirty. Iris recognition devices are
too interfering. It exposes the diseases and other physical ailments which one
may not wish to reveal. Voice recognition devices can fail to deliver results
in some conditions, especially when the person is suffering from a sore throat.
Face recognition system may not be perfect, but is advanced than the others.
A face
recognition system may use 2D or 3D images as a template to store in the
database. 2D images are common; 3D is less in use. Each model has its own
advantages and disadvantages. 2D recognition works better if the illuminating
light is moderate and is influenced by pose changes. Facial expressions and
changes in the face due to aging may affect the recognition rates in a face
recognition system. On the other hand, a biometric face recognition system
using 3D model database is getting cheaper and faster than before. But the 3D
model databases are very few.
A biometric face
recognition system using 2D model databases takes into consideration only the
two dimensions of the face. But the face is a 3D object! This makes the
expectation level rise, from a 3D model database, with regard to performance.
However, no experiment till now has been able to prove this popular belief. 3D
data capturing is not completely independent of light variations. Different
sources of light may create different models for the same face. Besides, they
are still more expensive as compared to a 2D face recognition system.
2D represents a
face by intensity variation and 3D represents a face by shape variation. A face
recognition system discriminates between faces on the basis of the intensity or
color of the features of a given face. 3D face recognition system discriminates
between faces on the basis of the shape of the features of a given face. As the
3D images use a more reliable base for recognition, they are considered to be
more accurate. However, a lot of improvement needs to be made in the field of
3D biometric face recognition system.
3D devices in the
market are not as matured as 2D devices. For this reason, many people are
reluctant to use 3D technology for facial detection. Constant improvements in
the 2D face recognition systems are also an affecting factor. Companies are
working on increasing the recognition rates of 2D biometric face recognition
systems. Improving the existing technology seems more feasible than developing
a new technology.
Experiments show
that the combination of 2D and 3D technology yields better results. The use of
multiple biometrics is more accurate than best possible sensor for single
biometric. An accuracy rate of 98.8% was recorded in a recent study of
biometric face recognition system using 2D and 3D images. The combination of
two technologies outperforms the use of single technology in face recognition
system.
face recognition system is the future of
security industry. However, at present it is not capable of handling the
security of the entire premise independently. Enhanced quality of images stored
in the database will give it the support to stand on its own.